(« back to home
page)
BILDESTON, St. Mary Magdalene
(TL 986 493),
SUFFOLK.
(Bedrock:
Upper Cretaceous, Upper Chalk.)
One of a group
of Suffolk churches identified by the late Birkin Haward as having been
part-built by the same master mason, 'Hawes of Occold', fl.
1410-1440.
%20-%20bildeston%201.jpg)
The question of whether or not it is
pertinent
to talk about 'the mediaeval mason' is a subject that has fiercely divided
architectural historians in recent decades, with many taking the view that the
very concept of 'authorship', defined as the consideration of a work of art as an expression of an
individual's creative skill and personality, had no currency before the Tudor
period. This supposition has coincided with the passing from fashion of
connoisseurship as an approach to art history more generally, whereby the identity of
individual artists was previously sought by stylistic analysis, in favour of
such modern obsessions as understanding art as an expression of ethnicity,
colonialism, gender, 'the male gaze', or similar issues, and since some academics have built their
reputations on the basis of these new studies, they naturally seek to defend them
vigorously.
This shift in the focus of art history has
not gone completely unchallenged however, albeit that some of the greatest
champions of 'the old school' have since passed away too. One such was Dr.
John Harvey (1911-97), whose biographical dictionary English Medieval Architects
(Gloucester, Alan Sutton, 1987) identified some 1,700 men of varying importance,
who appear to have been responsible for buildings or part-buildings in England
before 1550, and who argued that the only reason the men who designed mediaeval
buildings are so little known is that no-one makes the
effort to discover them. This theme was subsequently taken up at a local level in
Suffolk by the late Birkin Haward (1912-2002), who tried to group Suffolk's
mediaeval churches on the basis of their aisle arcades (Suffolk Mediaeval
Church Arcades, Hitcham, Suffolk Institute of Archaeology and History, 1993)
and who, in particular, went on to pick out on stylistic grounds, a dozen churches in mid
Suffolk that appear to have been part-built by the same master mason, referred
to by name in a building estimate for work at Wingfield church as 'Hawe[s],
mason of Ocolte' (Master Mason Hawes of Occold, Ipswich, Suffolk
Institute of Archaeology and History, 2000). The validity of this exercise is ultimately for the
reader to decide, but the examples illustrated on this web-site will seek to promote it.
Indeed, the present writer has attempted to identify another group of Suffolk
churches using Haward's methodology, centred on and around St. George's church,
Stowlangtoft, and these can be examined separately.
|
Bildeston is one of
Suffolk's most attractive villages although the church stands half a mile to
the east down a narrow country lane, marking the site of an earlier
settlement. It is quite large and in spite of the Ordnance Survey's
contradictory symbol, it does have a W. tower, albeit not the tall
one recorded by Pevsner on his visit in 1961 as a large part of that
collapsed fourteen years later and was replaced by the present, inadequate, upper stage
in wood, with its narrow surmounting spire. The rest of the building consists of an aisled
nave and chancel constructed as one (i.e. without an intervening chancel
arch), and an ambitious S. porch. The nave arcades are five bays long but the
chancel extends a further two bays, the S. chapel, a further one, and the N.
chapel (now the organ chamber), a further bay and a half, beyond which there is a diminutive vestry. The church is chiefly
Perpendicular in style but a little Decorated work survives, as seen in the
three-light E. window to the N. aisle with reticulated tracery and, perhaps,
in the two-light N. window to the sanctuary (in the very short section of
chancel wall east of the vestry) where the tracery is
curvilinear, although if the latter is genuine mediaeval work, it must be
re-set, for the sanctuary otherwise is now wholly Victorian (a state of
affairs unnoticed by Pevsner). The Perpendicular work appears to derive from two building phases, with the S. porch
being of a different date to the rest, and although this is the later piece, it
will be convenient to consider it first.
%20-%20bildeston%203.jpg)
The porch,
then, is large, angle-buttressed,
and altogether so similar to those to be seen in the immediate area at
St. Peter's, Felsham,
All Saints', Hitcham and
St Mary's, Preston St. Mary,
that it must surely be by the same unknown hand. (See
the photograph, left, taken from the southeast.) Decorated on the S. front with
four tiers of flushwork arches,
canopied niches on the buttresses above the first tier of off-sets, and a
third niche in the centre, the outer doorway bears an inner wave moulding springing from semicircular shafts and two outer hollows
decorated at intervals with carved leaves and animal faces, set in a square
surround with narrow crocketed pinnacles at the sides and large flowers in
the spandrels. The side windows (as at Felsham and Hitcham but not
Preston St. Mary) are two-light and segmental-arched, with drop tracery and castellated supertransoms between the two tiers of
reticulation units. The inner doorway displays two hollow mouldings,
decorated with shields and crowns, and a hood-mould decorated with
flowers, springing from lion label stops, all set in
a square surround with shields in the spandrels. The work can probably
be dated to c. 1470 by association with circumstantial evidence at Felsham
and Hitcham.
However,
as notable as this is, the earlier Perpendicular work at Bildeston is more so, for - thanks to the
scholarship of the late Birkin Haward - it appears to be
assignable to the master mason Hawes of Occold,
whose work can probably also be seen at Debenham and
Wickham Skeith,
and - in this writer's opinion - at Thorndon,
among other places, based on the form of the nave arcades where they exist,
and otherwise, on the window traceries. From the examination of these
two elements of design, it is possible to draw up a list of at least four
that can usually (though not invariably) be associated with this mason,
namely:
1. arcade
piers composed of four major and four
minor semicircular shafts, in which the major shafts bear fillets
(raised flat bands running down their full length) and the minor
shafts sometimes do (see the photograph, right);
2.
elaborate carved capitals in the form of angels or foliage, which
extend continuously all round the piers
(suggesting, in Haward's view, that Hawes was himself a skilled carver);
3.
three-light
windows with strong mullions (i.e. mullions that continue all the way up
to the arch head with no diminution in thickness), stepped lights topped by castellated
supertransoms, and drop tracery beneath depressed
segmental-pointed arches;
4. nave
and chancel roofs constructed with alternating tie beam and
hammerbeam trusses, yet wholly without collars, suggesting that
Hawes had his own preferred master carpenter who worked with him.
All these
elements are present
here (see also the carved capitals, both
from the N. arcade, illustrated at the foot of the page) and if
these are still not considered sufficient to associate the work with
Hawes of Occold, then confirmation of the date may provide further help
for I am informed by Dr. Simon Cotton that a bequest exists in a
Norwich Consistory Court will, dated 1420, in which John Hastyng,
chaplain, leaves 20s to the new work ['novum opus'] at Byldyston.
The
church interior is as impressive as the exterior, even though there are few features of note apart
from the tall
aisle arcades. As mentioned above, there is no chancel arch, and the
tower is separated from the nave by a wall containing a doorway. The nave roof (seen left,
viewed from the west) appears to be original and is, indeed, constructed with alternating tie
beams and hammerbeams, but unfortunately, the angels that once adorned the
latter, survived the Cromwellian iconoclasts period only to be destroyed in the
mid-eighteenth century after an excitable iconoclastic sermon by the Methodist, George Whitefield,
and although the chancel was provided with replacements a hundred
years
later, these are very malnourished affairs. The font is
Perpendicular but worn, and features the symbols of the Evangelists
alternating with figures of angels on its eight faces, the latter,
predictably, all with their heads broken off.
%20-%20bildeston%205.jpg)
%20-%20bildeston%206.JPG)
[Other churches featured on this web-site where
Hawes of Occold appears to have worked include Bedingfield,
Bramford, Debenham, Thorndon, Wetheringsett, Wickam Skeith and Wingfield in Suffolk,
and Dickleburgh, just across the county border in Norfolk.] |